Debit Card vs. Credit Card for Online Payments

While both types of cards are used for online payments, you will undoubtedly go through a different experience with each. We brought in the experts to weigh the pros and cons of using a credit card vs. a debit card for online payments.


Debit Card: Impossible To Get Into Debt

It's impossible to spend more money than you have on your debit card because of this. The result is that you cannot get into debt. Withdrawing cash from an ATM that isn't part of your bank's network, though, may cost you a charge. If you use a POS terminal to make purchases, you can request cash back to avoid these costs.

Credit Card: Safer

Credit cards serve primarily as a safety net, keeping your money separate from the rest of the world. Even if your card is stolen or misplaced, your money is protected. Card issuers' zero-liability policies provide an additional layer of security. Any false charges that happen are not your responsibility. Even before they begin their inquiry, some banks may credit your account with the stolen cash.

Although credit cards are more secure when purchasing online, this isn't always the case. Fraudsters can still steal your account number and use it to make fictitious purchases. Credit cards, on the other hand, provide liability protection in the event of fraud, making them the safer choice for e-commerce.

Gerrid Smith, CEO & Founder of Property Tax Loan Pros

Credit Card: Allows You to Divide Your Debt and Pay Them Monthly

Use a credit card if you are paying for a large purchase which you can get on installments. What's good with credit cards is that you can divide your debts and pay them on a monthly basis making it easier to settle such. In my case, whenever we buy appliances for home use, I always find it ideal to get such on installments so that it won't be a huge expense on the monthly budget.

Debit Card: Will Control Overspending

Use a debit card if it's just a regular bill since, with cash, you usually overspend. Say, for example, you will pay $29 for a certain thing; with cash, you won't actually notice where the rest went, especially if you withdraw a hundred from your account, but with debit payments, it's all detailed on your monthly statement of account. 

Aviad Faruz, CEO/ Owner FARUZO

Credit Card: Provides Protection From Fraud

On the whole, a credit card offers much more protection from both the issuer and the government; therefore, if you were to be the subject of fraud, then you are likely to be able to reclaim the money that was taken, whereas a debit card you almost certainly cannot. Additionally, using but paying off your credit card each month is great for your credit. For these reasons, a credit card is much better for online payments.

Debit Card: Helps Limit Spending

However, if you have control issues when it comes to spending on your credit card and you feel you are in danger of reaching your limit or being unable to pay your monthly bill, thus incurring interest, fees, and other debt issues, then it may be safer to avoid getting into the habit of using your credit card for online purchases.

Scott Nelson, CEO of MoneyNerd Ltd

Debit Cards: Help To Avoid Debt, But They Run Out Of Money

Debit cards have the advantage of not putting you in debt when you use them. They restrict your spending to the funds in your bank account. There will also be no monthly interest payments. If you run out of money, however, your card will be refused unless you enroll in an overdraft protection program, in which case the bank will cover the cost of the transaction. If you don't, and an unexpected expense arises, you may not have enough money in your account to make the transaction, I believe. 

Credit Cards: Are Less Risky, But They Can Be Lost

When you use a credit card, there is a period of time between when you make the transaction and when you must pay. This offers you more time to catch mistakes and contest them while keeping your bank account untouched. 

When you use a debit card (or criminals with your card and PIN), the money is taken directly from your checking account. Credit cards also provide fraud protection. However, most debit cards now provide optional zero liability coverage; I am convinced. 

Daniel Carter, SEO Manager at Snowpads

Debit Cards: Do Not Have Annual Fees, But They Do Have Other Fees

Using debit cards saves money as well. They don't usually levy yearly fees like certain credit cards. Furthermore, several banks provide free checking accounts with no monthly fees. If you need cash from an ATM, you can usually receive it for free if you use your debit card at ATMs that are linked with your bank. 

Using ATMs from other banks, on the other hand, may result in ATM surcharges. If you don't qualify for a waiver, some checking accounts (which you'll need for a normal debit card) levy maintenance fees, but a checking account is nearly a requirement. A credit card isn't one of them, I believe.

Credit Cards: Can Help Or Harm Your Credit

Maintaining a credit card account allows you to create a solid credit history or maintain good credit. Debit cards have no impact on your credit score. Some die-hard debit card users may argue that credit scores are irrelevant because they would never need to borrow money, yet credit scores are crucial. You may need to borrow money in the future (to buy a house or car, for example), and beginning from zero is difficult. 

If you pay off your credit card balances in full every month, you won't have to pay any interest. However, if you miss a payment, your credit score may suffer, which isn't usually the case with debit cards, I believe.

Susan Smith, Marketing Manager at Velden Engineering

Debit Cards: Are Convenient For Small Purchases, But They Are Inconvenient For Large Ones

Merchants are charged fees to process your payments, and debit card swipe fees are often cheaper than credit card swipe rates (although there are exceptions). As a result, some retailers impose minimum purchase requirements when paying with a credit card, such as a $10 minimum. When you use a debit card, on the other hand, you can often avoid swipe fees, lowering the expenses of your favorite companies. 

However, one disadvantage of debit cards is that if you make a substantial purchase, you're pushed to spend right away because the money is promptly deducted from your account. You don't have to pay back what you borrowed right away because credit card purchases are loans. This makes huge purchases easier to manage. 

Credit Cards: Provide Rewards, But Debit Has Its Own Set Of Benefits

Credit cards, in general, offer better benefits than debit cards in the form of sign-up bonuses, discounts, cashback, and travel points if you're motivated by bonuses. Some credit cards even include extended warranties and limited travel insurance with purchases. 

While the normal debit card does not provide such perks, a select group of debit cards linked to rewards checking accounts do. There are a variety of cashback debit cards available, for example. Read the tiny print on some rewards debit cards since they may have fees or spending limits that overshadow the benefits, I am convinced.

Julian Goldie, CEO of Goldie Agency

(Most) Credit Cards: Come With Zero-Fraud Liability

Using a credit card adds an extra degree of fraud protection and simplifies the refund process. While the federal government provides some protections for both debit and credit card transactions, most credit cards go a step further by providing their own type of zero-fraud liability. 

If someone steals your credit card number and uses it to make an online purchase, you'll almost certainly not be held accountable for any of it if you report it quickly. Unfortunately, the same cannot be stated with debit card purchases.

Bram Jansen, Chief Editor of vpnAlert

Credit Cards: Make It Infinitely Easier To Dispute Charges

Dispute resolution is one of the reasons credit is preferable to debit for online purchases. What happens if you order something online and it is damaged or never arrives? What if you don't receive your order? If there is a problem with your purchase, you may be able to withhold payment or dispute a charge if you pay using your credit card. 

The majority of the time, your card issuer will also handle the investigation details. You only need to pick up the phone and call them if you receive something funny or broken in the mail.

If you used a debit card instead of a credit card, the situation might not be as straightforward.

When you pay with a debit card, the money is taken out of your account right away, leaving you without cash until you can settle the disagreement with the retailer on your own. Even if your bank agrees to help you, you'll still have to bear the burden of evidence.

Neil Shaw, Founder & CEO at Lottery Sambad

Was this article helpful?
About the Author